Explore Casey’s Toledo menu of hand-formed burgers, specialty pizzas, sandwiches, appetizers and tacos.
Casey’s is located at 5534 Secor Road in West Toledo, near Secor Road and Laskey Road. You can dine inside, enjoy your food on our seasonal patio, call 419-984-5011 for pickup or order through a participating delivery service.
Hand-Formed Burgers, Tacos and Sandwiches on Casey’s Toledo Menu
Our burger menu includes half-pound specialty burgers, classic smash burgers and creative combinations made with flavorful toppings and sauces. However, burgers are not your only option. You can also choose grilled blackened fish tacos or a fish sandwich when you want something different.
Specialty Pizza in West Toledo
Next, explore our specialty pizzas prepared with house-made, hand-stretched dough. Along with familiar favorites, Casey’s Toledo menu includes several distinctive flavor combinations.
For example, you can choose a classic pepperoni or loaded supreme pizza. Alternatively, try the Cheeseburger Pizza, Taco Pizza, Margherita or Wild Mushroom and Chèvre.
Because our pizzas are easy to share, they are a good choice for dinner with friends. They are also a convenient option to enjoy during one of Casey’s weekly events.
House-Made Appetizers and Toledo Bar Food
To begin your meal, order an appetizer for yourself or share something around the table. Casey’s appetizers include crispy chicken dippers, loaded fries, Italian Stallion poppers, fried mushrooms and other satisfying bar snacks.
Unlike ordinary heat-and-serve bar food, many of our appetizers are prepared in-house. In addition, you can stop in during happy hour to enjoy selected appetizers at special prices.
Food, Drinks and Weekly Events at Casey’s
Casey’s is more than a place to stop for one drink. Instead, you can meet friends for food, relax during happy hour and stay for Music Bingo, Name That Tune, karaoke, pool tournaments or one of our seasonal patio events.
Before your visit, check our weekly events schedule. Then, come early enough to order from the kitchen and settle in before the entertainment begins.
Casey’s Toledo Menu for Dine-In, Pickup and Delivery
For pickup, call Casey’s at 419-984-5011. You can also dine inside or enjoy your meal on the seasonal patio when it is open.
Additionally, Casey’s works with participating delivery services. As a result, you can enjoy many of your favorite menu items at home.
Order from Casey’s Toledo Menu
First, explore our hand-formed burgers, sandwiches and tacos. Whether you want a familiar favorite or a more creative combination, each selection is made to be satisfying.
Then, complete your meal with an appetizer or specialty pizza. Finally, check our weekly schedule and stay for one of Casey’s regular events.
We Have Some Pretty Special Burgers
Loaded Bacon Cheeseburger
$13.50
For a classic choice, try the Loaded Bacon Cheeseburger with American cheese, thick bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Casey’s Custom Burger
Starting at $9
Includes a grilled beef patty, bun and house fries. Additional toppings are priced individually.
Midnight Blue Burger $13.50
In addition, the Midnight Blue Burger brings together blue cheese, bacon, caramelized onions and bourbon barbecue glaze.
Mushroom Burger $12.50
For a familiar favorite, the Mushroom Swiss Burger pairs grilled mushrooms with melted Swiss cheese and mayonnaise.
Nacho Burger $11.50
For extra heat, the Nacho Burger adds cheddar cheese sauce, jalapeños, tomato, red onion and chipotle aioli.
Tacos and Smash Burgers
Smash Burger Platter $11.25
For crisp edges and familiar flavors, the Smash Burger Platter combines American cheese, mustard, onion and pickle.
Oklahoma Smash Burger $11.25
Meanwhile, the Oklahoma Smash Burger features thin-sliced sweet onions grilled directly into the beef.
Grilled Blackened Fish Tacos $11.50
Three warm tortillas filled with seasoned blackened fish, crisp cabbage slaw and house-made lime crema.
For something especially hearty, try one of our hot sandwiches or paninis with house-made french fries.
Blackened Fish Sandwich $12.50
Grilled blackened fish with a smoky spice crust, layered with our house-made lime crema and crisp, creamy cole slaw on a toasted bun. Comes with a side of house-made french fries.
The Italian Stack $12.50
Next, explore Casey’s hot paninis and sandwiches, each served with house-made fries.
Specialty Pizza in West Toledo
Choose from specialty pizzas prepared with our house-made, hand-stretched dough. In addition to familiar favorites, the menu includes several distinctive Casey’s combinations. Also, our specialty pizzas include both familiar combinations and creative Casey’s favorites.
Cheeseburger Pizza $14 small / $17 large
House-made, hand-stretched dough topped with a zesty ketchup and mustard sauce, seasoned ground beef, onions, and melted cheese. Finished with fresh lettuce, tomato, and dill pickle for the full cheeseburger experience.
Magherita Pizza $13 small / $16 large
Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and roasted garlic on our house-made crust, finished with olive oil, Parmesan, and fresh basil.
Wild Mushroom & Chèvre $14 small / $17 large
A garlic olive oil base topped with roasted mushrooms, garlic, red onions, and fire-roasted peppers. Finished with creamy chèvre, melted mozzarella, shaved Parmesan, and fresh basil.
Pepperoni Powerhouse $14 small / $17 large
Loaded with pepperoni under the cheese and piled even higher on top, all over our house-made crust with rich sauce and melted mozzarella. A true pepperoni lover’s pizza.
Puttanesca Pizza $15.50 small . $18.50 large
Roma tomatoes, Kalamata olives, artichokes, feta, and garlic over our house-made crust with melted mozzarella. Finished with olive oil, Parmesan, and fresh basil.
Loaded Supreme Pizza $16 small / $19 large
Pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives piled high over our house-made crust with rich sauce and melted mozzarella
Taco Pizza $14 small / $17 large
Seasoned ground beef, onions, and melted cheese on our house-made crust, finished with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and black olives. Served with your choice of salsa or sour cream.
Very Veggie Pizza $14 small / $17 large
A fresh mix of roasted peppers, red onions, black olives, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, and Roma tomatoes over our house-made crust with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and Parmesan, finished with basil.
House Made Appetizers and Bar Snacks on the Casey’s Toledo Menu
Meanwhile, our appetizers are easy to share with the table or enjoy alongside your favorite drink.
Crispy Dippers and Fries $9.50
Hand-breaded all-white chicken tenderloins fried golden and crispy, served with a basket of hot seasoned fries and your choice of dipping sauce. Perfect for sharing… or not
Pizza Bowl starting at $8
Pizza Bowl (low-carb favorite) – A hearty bowl of savory pizza sauce, gooey melted mozzarella, and all your favorite toppings, baked to a bubbling, golden finish.
Ingredients priced individually
Loaded French Fries $10
A sizzling skillet of indulgence — our crispy house fries are layered with onions and seasoned ground beef, cheddar cheese sauce, then blanketed with mozzarella and baked to golden brown in a cast iron skillet.
Finally, add an appetizer or side for the table.
Italian Stallion Poppers $9.50
Jalapeños stuffed with Italian sausage and a creamy cheese blend, topped with melted mozzarella and baked until golden and bubbling. Creamy, spicy, and loaded with bold flavor.
Basket of Fries $7.50
Crispy, golden fries served hot and lightly seasoned. Simple, classic, and always a good call.
Crispy Fried Mushrooms $9.50
Whole mushrooms, hand-dipped in our house-made seasoned batter and fried golden brown. Crispy on the outside, tender and juicy inside — served with your choice of ranch, chipotle aioli, or garlic butter for dipping.
Questions About Casey’s Toledo Menu
What food does Casey’s Toledo serve?
Casey’s serves hand-formed burgers, specialty pizzas, fish tacos, sandwiches, chicken dippers, loaded fries and house-made appetizers. Menu choices and food specials may change periodically.
Can I order food for pickup from Casey’s?
Yes. Call Casey’s at 419-984-5011 to place a pickup order. Pickup availability depends on the kitchen’s current operating hours.
Does Casey’s Toledo offer food delivery?
Casey’s offers delivery through participating third-party delivery services. Available menu items, prices and delivery hours may differ by service.
Where is Casey’s located in Toledo?
Casey’s is located at 5534 Secor Road in West Toledo, near Secor Road and Laskey Road. Guests can dine inside or enjoy the seasonal outdoor patio when it is open.
Order Food From Casey’s
Call 419-984-5011 to place a pickup order. Dine inside, enjoy your meal on the patio, or order through a participating delivery service.