Casey’s Specialty Burgers: Which One Should You Order?

Casey’s specialty burgers give Toledo burger lovers several ways to satisfy a craving. You can keep things familiar with bacon and cheese, try the sweet and smoky Midnight Blue Burger, turn up the heat with the Nacho Burger or enjoy the crisp edges of a smash burger.

Every Casey’s burger starts with beef that we form in our kitchen. From there, the toppings create distinctly different choices. Therefore, the best burger for you depends on whether you want something classic, smoky, spicy or loaded with grilled onions.

This guide will help you choose. You can also see our current selections, prices and other house-made food on the Casey’s Toledo menu.

What Makes Casey’s Specialty Burgers Different?

A good neighborhood bar burger should feel like a complete meal instead of an afterthought beside your drink. It should arrive hot, hold together and deliver plenty of flavor without becoming unnecessarily complicated.

At Casey’s, we build our burgers for exactly that kind of meal. Our kitchen forms the beef, cooks each burger to order and pairs it with toppings that give every selection its own personality.

Moreover, Casey’s is an independent West Toledo bar and grill. We are proud to serve satisfying food in a relaxed setting where you can stop for dinner, meet friends or eat before one of our weekly events.

Choose the Loaded Bacon Cheeseburger for a Classic

Start with the Loaded Bacon Cheeseburger when you want familiar flavors and a hearty meal. American cheese and thick bacon bring the richness, while lettuce and tomato add freshness. Mayonnaise completes the classic bar-and-grill combination.

This is one of the easiest Casey’s specialty burgers to choose if you love bacon cheeseburgers and do not want to venture too far from a proven favorite.

It also works well for a first visit. You get a satisfying introduction to Casey’s hand-formed burgers without an especially spicy or unusual topping combination.

Try the Midnight Blue Burger for Sweet and Smoky Flavor

The Midnight Blue Burger takes a bolder approach. It combines blue cheese, bacon, caramelized onions and bourbon barbecue glaze.

First, the blue cheese provides a distinctive tang. Then, the bacon adds salt and smoke. Meanwhile, the caramelized onions and barbecue glaze bring sweetness that balances the stronger flavors.

Choose this burger when you enjoy blue cheese or want something more adventurous than an ordinary cheeseburger. Because the toppings are rich, it is especially satisfying when you arrive ready for a substantial dinner.

Pick the Mushroom Burger for a Savory Favorite

Mushrooms and Swiss cheese belong together, especially on a hot burger. Casey’s Mushroom Burger combines grilled mushrooms, melted Swiss cheese and mayonnaise for a creamy, savory selection.

Although it has plenty of flavor, it does not bring the heat of the Nacho Burger or the stronger blue cheese flavor of the Midnight Blue. As a result, it lands comfortably between a basic cheeseburger and one of our more adventurous combinations.

The Mushroom Burger is a dependable choice for anyone who already knows that mushrooms and Swiss are their preferred burger toppings.

Turn Up the Heat With the Nacho Burger

The Nacho Burger moves in a spicier direction with cheddar cheese sauce, jalapeños, tomato, red onion and chipotle aioli.

The cheese sauce makes it rich, while the jalapeños and chipotle aioli add heat. At the same time, tomato and red onion provide freshness and contrast.

Order this one when you want a burger with extra personality. However, if you prefer mild flavors, another Casey’s specialty burger may suit you better.

Keep It Simple With a Casey’s Custom Burger

Sometimes you know exactly what belongs on your burger. That is where the Casey’s Custom Burger comes in.

Start with the burger and add the available cheese, vegetables, sauces and other toppings you prefer. You can keep it simple or build a more substantial combination.

The custom option also works well for customers who want to leave off a particular ingredient. If you have an allergy or dietary concern, please speak with your server before ordering. Our kitchen will explain what accommodations may be available, although cross-contact can occur in a working bar kitchen.

Smash Burger or Oklahoma Smash Burger?

Casey’s also offers smash-style choices for customers who prefer thinner beef with flavorful browned edges.

The Smash Burger Platter brings together American cheese, mustard, onion and pickle. It is a straightforward combination built around familiar burger toppings.

The Oklahoma Smash Burger handles the onions differently. Thinly sliced sweet onions cook directly against the beef, allowing them to soften, brown and become part of the burger itself. American cheese finishes the combination.

Choose the regular Smash Burger when you want the classic mixture of mustard, pickles and onions. On the other hand, choose the Oklahoma Smash when grilled onions are the flavor you want to lead every bite.

For a broader look at our burger selection, visit our main Burgers in Toledo page.

Which Casey’s Burger Matches Your Craving?

Here is the easiest way to narrow down your choice:

• For a classic bacon cheeseburger, order the Loaded Bacon Cheeseburger.

• For sweet, smoky and tangy flavors, try the Midnight Blue Burger.

• For mushrooms and melted Swiss, choose the Mushroom Burger.

• For jalapeños and chipotle heat, order the Nacho Burger.

• For your own topping combination, build a Casey’s Custom Burger.

• For crisp edges and traditional toppings, choose the Smash Burger Platter.

• For beef cooked with plenty of sweet onions, try the Oklahoma Smash Burger.

Of course, you can choose a different burger on each visit and decide which one earns a place in your regular rotation.

Pair Your Burger With a Night at Casey’s

Casey’s specialty burgers can be the beginning of an entire evening. Meet friends for dinner, enjoy a drink and stay for Music Bingo, Name That Tune, karaoke or another neighborhood event.

Check the Casey’s weekly events schedule before visiting. You can also begin with happy hour at Casey’s and order dinner when the kitchen opens.

During warmer weather, enjoy your burger on our seasonal patio. The patio gives groups room to settle in with food and drinks while enjoying a Toledo evening outside.

Because kitchen hours can vary by day, check the current hours on our menu page before making your plans.

Visit Casey’s for Hand-Formed Burgers in West Toledo

Casey’s is located at 5534 Secor Road in West Toledo, near Secor and Laskey. We have been part of Toledo’s LGBTQ+ community for more than 30 years, and today we proudly welcome people from every walk of life.

Come in for a Casey’s specialty burger, meet friends for drinks or make dinner the beginning of an evening of entertainment.

You can dine inside, enjoy the seasonal patio or call 419-984-5011 to ask about pickup during current kitchen hours.

Get directions to Casey’s Toledo.

Frequently Asked Questions About Casey’s Burgers

Are Casey’s burgers formed in-house?

Yes. Casey’s forms its burger patties in the kitchen instead of relying on ordinary preformed heat-and-serve burgers.

Does Casey’s offer smash burgers?

Yes. Casey’s offers a Smash Burger Platter and an Oklahoma Smash Burger. The Oklahoma version features thinly sliced sweet onions cooked directly with the beef.

Can I customize my burger?

Casey’s offers a Custom Burger that allows you to select from available toppings. Additional toppings may cost extra.

Where is Casey’s Toledo located?

Casey’s is located at 5534 Secor Road in West Toledo, near Secor and Laskey.

Can I order a burger for pickup?

Pickup may be available during current kitchen hours. Call Casey’s at 419-984-5011 to confirm availability and place an order.