Specialty Pizza in West Toledo: Casey’s House-Made Pizzas

If you are looking forpizza and drinks in Toledo, or a specialty pizza in West Toledo, Casey’s offers much more than a basic bar pie. We build our pizzas on house-made crust and offer familiar favorites alongside combinations such as Reuben, Taco, Margherita, Cheeseburger, Wild Mushroom & Chèvre, and Puttanesca.

Pizza fits naturally into a night at Casey’s. Share one with friends during happy hour, order dinner before Music Bingo or Name That Tune, or enjoy a pizza on our seasonal patio. You can also choose a pizza bowl when you want the sauce, cheese, and toppings without the crust.

What Makes Casey’s West Toledo Specialty Pizza Different?

Casey’s is a neighborhood bar and grill, not a national pizza chain. We make our crust in-house and build pizzas that match the kind of relaxed night our customers enjoy. Some choices begin with recognizable classics. Others use ingredients you may not expect to find on a neighborhood bar menu.

That variety makes Casey’s a good choice for groups. One table can order a traditional pepperoni or Supreme pizza while another tries a Reuben or Wild Mushroom & Chèvre. As a result, everyone can find something that suits their appetite without leaving the group or missing the evening’s event.

West Toledo Specialty Pizza to try at Casey’s

The current Casey’s Toledo menu includes several pizzas with distinct flavors. Menu items and availability can change, so check the menu before your visit.

Cheeseburger Pizza

The Cheeseburger Pizza combines two neighborhood-bar favorites. It starts with a ketchup-and-mustard sauce, seasoned ground beef, onion, and cheese. After baking, we finish it with tomato, lettuce, and dill pickle.

Choose this pizza when part of your table wants a burger and the rest wants something easy to share. The pickles and classic burger toppings give each slice a familiar cheeseburger flavor.

Taco Pizza

Our Taco Pizza starts with seasoned ground beef, onion, and cheese. Tomato, lettuce, and black olives complete the pizza, with salsa or sour cream served on the side.

This is a practical group order because guests can add salsa or sour cream to their own slices. Therefore, each person can adjust the flavor without changing the entire pizza.

Reuben Pizza is a much more than bar pizza in West Toledo

The Reuben Pizza turns a deli favorite into a shareable pie. It features a Thousand Island base, corned beef, sauerkraut, and melted cheese.

If you already enjoy a Reuben sandwich, this pizza offers those savory and tangy flavors in a different form. It also gives the table an alternative to a traditional red-sauce pizza.

Margherita Pizza

The Margherita brings together Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic, olive oil, Parmesan, and fresh basil on our house-made crust.

Although the ingredients are straightforward, the combination delivers plenty of flavor. It is a strong choice for guests who want a meatless pizza that still feels complete.

Wild Mushroom & Chèvre Pizza is Truely a West Toledo Specialty Pizza

For a richer meatless option, try the Wild Mushroom & Chèvre. It combines a wild mushroom blend, roasted garlic, red onion, roasted peppers, chèvre, mozzarella, olive oil, Parmesan, and basil.

The mushrooms provide a savory base, while the chèvre adds a creamy, tangy contrast. Consequently, this pizza works well when your table wants something beyond the usual vegetable pie.

Puttanesca Pizza

The Puttanesca Pizza features Roma tomatoes, Kalamata olives, artichokes, feta, mozzarella, garlic, olive oil, Parmesan, and basil.

Olives, feta, and artichokes give this pizza a bold, salty character. Consider pairing it with a simpler pizza when ordering for a larger group.

Very Veggie Pizza

The Very Veggie Pizza layers tomato sauce with roasted peppers, red onion, black olives, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, Roma tomatoes, mozzarella, Parmesan, and basil.

This option offers several vegetables in every slice. It is a useful choice when you want a traditional tomato base with more toppings and texture.

Supreme and Pepperoni Favorites

Casey’s also offers familiar choices for guests who prefer the classics. The Supreme combines pepperoni, sausage, red and white onion, green pepper, and black olives. Meanwhile, the Pepperoni Powerhouse doubles down with pepperoni beneath the cheese and more pepperoni on top.

These pizzas pair well with one of Casey’s more unusual specialty pies. Order one familiar pizza and one adventurous option so the whole table has a comfortable starting point.

Want the Toppings Without the Crust? Try a Pizza Bowl

Casey’s Pizza Bowl brings together savory pizza sauce, melted mozzarella, and your choice of toppings without a crust. It is a useful alternative for guests limiting carbohydrates or anyone who would rather eat their pizza with a fork.

Because you can select the toppings, the pizza bowl does not limit you to one preset flavor. Review the current menu and ask your bartender or server about available choices.

Pizza for Happy Hour, Events, and the Patio

Pizza at Casey’s is part of a complete night out. Meet after work, order a pie for the table, and then stay for one of our regular events. Tuesday Music Bingo and Friday Name That Tune give groups something to do while they eat, talk, and enjoy drinks.

On good-weather days, you can also enjoy dinner at our West Toledo patio bar. A pizza is easy to share while friends settle in, move around the patio, or join the evening’s activity.

If you plan to eat before an event, arrive early enough to order during current kitchen hours. Bar hours and kitchen hours are different, and the kitchen closes before the bar on late nights. Check the weekly events and current schedule before making plans.

What Goes Well With Casey’s Pizza?

For a larger table, pair pizza with one of Casey’s shareable appetizers. House-battered fried mushrooms, Italian Jalapeño Poppers, loaded fries, onion rings, and Casey’s Crispy Dippers give the group more flavors to try.

You do not need to over-order at the beginning. Start with an appetizer if friends are arriving at different times. Then, once the group is together, choose one or two pizzas based on everyone’s preferences.

Visit Casey’s for Specialty Pizza in West Toledo

Casey’s combines specialty pizza in West Toledo with a friendly neighborhood-bar atmosphere, weekly entertainment, happy hour, and a spacious seasonal patio. Whether you choose Cheeseburger, Reuben, Margherita, Wild Mushroom & Chèvre, Puttanesca, or a classic pepperoni pizza, you can make dinner part of the evening instead of a separate stop.

Visit Casey’s at 5534 Secor Road, Toledo, Ohio 43623, near Secor and Laskey. Call 419-984-5011 with questions about current kitchen hours or menu availability.